Susan (lil_shepherd) wrote,
Susan
lil_shepherd

Torchwood - Children of Earth

Started out promisingly, was stretched so thin it was hard to stay awake through the middle, and ended up, this evening, as unrealistic, sentimental, manipulative twaddle. Not to mention being totally out of character.

It tried to tug the heart strings so hard that they twanged into comedy. Hey, didn't any of these soldiers have kids themselves? Didn't they have brothers, sisters, nephews, nieces? Where did they come from, anyway? Surely most of them would have been rounding up kids in Afghanistan? Actually, I doubt it...

People are programmed to protect kids. You don't overturn that programming by an order from the PM. Really.

Keep it quiet? Tell that to the Iranians!

I suspect it was meant as trying to overturn the old Star Trek ethic, old and new - both "the need of the one can override the need of the many" and "there is no such thing as a no-win situation." Except they had to go and win.

This is RTD's revenge on the fans. Lead them down the garden path with a (totally out of character) love story between Jack and Ianto, bring in all the families, have Gwen get preggers (cripes, how much fan fiction has the man read?) and then destroy it all and thumb his nose at everyone.

Personally, I'd have dropped an atom bomb on the aliens at the start. Or on Torchwood: Cardiff.

Total crap.

ETA: I did not spoiler-cut this because much of the above is pretty general criticism. However there are large spoilers in the comments.
Tags: torchwood, tv
Subscribe

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 43 comments